5 Best Rated Margaritas on the Upper West Side

The Upper West Side of Manhattan is renowned for its cultural richness, leafy streets, and diverse dining scene. Among the many culinary delights that draw locals and visitors alike, the margarita holds a special place as a symbol of celebration, refreshment, and creativity. Whether you’re seeking a classic lime margarita, a frozen treat, or an inventive twist on the original, the UWS offers a selection of standout spots where the margarita is elevated to an art form. Five establishments in particular—Cilantro, Rancho Tequileria, Playa Betty’s, Tacombi, and Covacha—stand out for their exceptional takes on this beloved cocktail.

Cilantro, located at 485 Columbus Ave., has long been a neighborhood favorite for its relaxed Southwestern vibe and consistently strong drinks. The margaritas here are celebrated for their variety and potency, making Cilantro a go-to for casual gatherings and lively brunches. Guests can choose from a tempting array of flavors, including strawberry, mango, coconut, pomegranate, and wildberry, with the option to have their margarita frozen or on the rocks. The generous pours are available in three sizes—12 oz, 16 oz, or by the pitcher—ensuring there’s an option for every occasion, whether you’re sipping solo or sharing with friends. Cilantro’s margaritas are not only flavorful but also offer excellent value, and the convivial atmosphere, complete with free chips and salsa, makes it easy to linger over a second round. The friendly staff and welcoming setting further enhance the experience, making Cilantro a cornerstone of the UWS margarita scene.

Just a bit further uptown, Rancho Tequileria (located at 718 Amsterdam Ave.) brings an authentic taste of Mexico to the neighborhood, with a particular emphasis on tequila and mezcal. The margarita menu here is a testament to creativity and tradition, offering both the classic lime version and a wide selection of specialty flavors such as mango, pineapple, passion fruit, piña colada, guava, coconut, tamarindo, and prickly pear. Rancho Tequileria also features inventive house specialties like “La de Oro,” which combines Cuervo Gold Tequila with blood orange and agave nectar, and “La Caliente,” a spicy concoction with Don Julio Tequila and fresh jalapeño. For those who like to share, pitchers of margaritas are available, and happy hour—running daily from 4 to 7 pm and again late at night—offers excellent deals on both classic and specialty drinks. A must-visit for margarita enthusiasts who appreciate both authenticity and innovation.

For a completely different vibe, Playa Betty’s (located a 320 Amsterdam Ave.) brings a California beach spirit to the Upper West Side. Known for its fun, laid-back atmosphere and creative cocktails, Playa Betty’s is particularly famous for its frozen margaritas. The “Frozen Paloma,” a grapefruit margarita with Cuervo Silver, grapefruit, lime, and a pink peppercorn-salted rim, is a signature favorite, while the classic “Betty’s Marg” is always a crowd-pleaser. Happy hour specials make Playa Betty’s a popular destination for after-work drinks or weekend hangouts, with $9 frozen Palomas and Betty’s Margs served daily from 3 to 6 pm. The bar team is always experimenting with new flavors and seasonal twists, ensuring there’s something fresh and exciting on the menu. The beachy décor and communal tables make Playa Betty’s the perfect place to gather with friends, relax, and enjoy a margarita.

Tacombi, situated at 377 Amsterdam Avenue, started as a beachside taqueria in Mexico and has brought its relaxed, authentic taco culture to New York City. The margaritas at Tacombi are a study in simplicity and quality, focusing on fresh lime juice, quality tequila, and orange liqueur. Served on the rocks, Tacombi’s margaritas are crisp, balanced, and refreshing—perfect companions to the restaurant’s acclaimed Baja crispy fish tacos and homemade guacamole. The airy, open dining room and spacious outdoor seating area provide a laid-back setting that encourages lingering over drinks and conversation. Every margarita is a testament to the original spirit of the cocktail, making it a favorite for purists and foodies alike.

Rounding out the list is Covacha, a newer addition to the UWS margarita landscape, located at 368 Columbus Avenue. Covacha has quickly distinguished itself with its artisanal approach to both food and drink, drawing inspiration from the flavors of western Mexico and Jalisco. The margaritas here are crafted with care, often featuring small-batch tequilas, house-made infusions, and creative twists that reflect the season or the chef’s inspiration. While the classic margarita is always available and expertly balanced, Covacha frequently offers unique specials that showcase ingredients like hibiscus, tamarind, or fresh herbs. The festive, colorful interior and friendly service create a welcoming environment for both brunch and dinner. Covacha’s dedication to authenticity and innovation ensures that each visit offers something new to discover, making it a rising star on the UWS cocktail scene.

In conclusion, the Upper West Side offers an impressive array of margarita experiences, each with its own unique flair and approach. Cilantro stands out for its variety and strength, Rancho Tequileria for its creative flavors and festive atmosphere, Playa Betty’s for its frozen delights and California cool, Tacombi for its classic craftsmanship and laid-back vibe, and Covacha for its artisanal, ever-evolving creations. Whether you’re a margarita purist or an adventurous sipper, these five establishments represent the very best the UWS has to offer. Exploring them is not just a journey through the neighborhood’s cocktail culture, but also a celebration of the creativity and hospitality that define the Upper West Side. So next time you find yourself craving a margarita, you’ll know exactly where to go for a drink that’s as memorable as the neighborhood itself.