7 Unique UWS Stores to Buy Gifts For the Holidays

The Upper West Side is packed with unique, locally-owned shops that turn holiday gift-giving into an experience. Here are six standout venues, each offering something truly special for every type of recipient, from art lovers to foodies and opera fans.​

Runaway Poppy

Runaway Poppy is a boutique celebrated for its ever-changing selection of handmade ceramics, artisan home accents, and unique New York-inspired dishes and jewelry. Owner Cara Milling curates each piece with an eye for artistry and local flair, ensuring every item feels personal and distinctive. Thoughtfully designed store environment, making the act of gift hunting a genuine pleasure. Runaway Poppy located at 2244 Broadway (between W. 80th/81st Streets).​ Magpie located at 488 Amsterdam Ave. (between W. 83rd/84th Streets).

Book Culture

Book Culture is more than a bookstore—it’s a community hub that stocks literature alongside unique stationery, posters, and gift items you won’t find elsewhere on the UWS. The staff is known for personalized recommendations, making every visit feel expertly tailored. Make Book Culture your stop for memorable, literary gifts that speak to every age and taste. Located at 536 W. 112th Steet (between Amsterdam Ave. & Broadway).​

Teddy’s Collection

Teddy’s Collection is regarded for its imaginative toys, plush gifts, and one-of-a-kind children’s finds, making it a top pick for anyone shopping for young ones or collectors. Their shelves are lined with novelty items and the latest trends in kids’ gifts, so you’ll always find something to delight your recipients on the holidays. Located at 324 Columbus Ave. (between W. 75th/76th Streets.​

Zabar’s

Zabar’s is an iconic New York food emporium offering gourmet delicacies, specialty treats, and curated gift baskets, perfect for holiday hosts, food lovers, and anyone craving a taste of tradition. Their legendary coffee, smoked salmon, rugelach, and kitchenware are just some of the favorites here. Zabar’s reputation for quality and old-school NYC hospitality makes every gift a true classic. Located at 2245 Broadway (between W. 80th/81st Streets).​

Met Opera Shop

The Met Opera Shop is a haven for music aficionados and lovers of performance art. Stocked with exclusive opera recordings, jewelry, scarves, and elegant accessories inspired by the Met’s history, it offers a distinctly cultured take on holiday giving. For those who treasure New York’s opera scene, this shop ensures your gift is both sophisticated and memorable. Located at 140 W. 65th Street – Lincoln Center.​

Grand Bazaar

Grand Bazaar, open on Sundays, stands out for its rotating lineup of independent merchants, local artists, and vintage curators. Here, you’ll browse an ever-changing selection of crafts, artisanal goodies, antiques, and rare finds. Known as NYC biggest curated weekly market. The Bazaar feels festive even on regular weekends, but during the holidays it’s a treasure trove of one-of-a-kind gifts that support local makers. Located at 100 W. 77th Street/Columbus Ave.

Magpie

Magpie enchants visitors with whimsical, eco-friendly treasures including hand-made calendars, candles, bath products, and stationery. Every corner of Magpie is designed to surprise—gift seekers lose track of time exploring thoughtfully selected gifts that support independent makers and sustainable practices. Magpie located at 488 Amsterdam Ave. (between W. 83rd/84th Streets).

No matter your gift list, these Upper West Side staples are rich in character, variety, and the unique spirit of New York. Giving from these shops ensures your holiday presents are as memorable as the people who receive them.